Pin it
The indulgent combination of caramelized sugar, custardy bread, and vanilla-scented cream transforms ordinary French toast into something truly extraordinary with this crème brûlée-inspired version. The overnight preparation means you can wake up to an effortlessly elegant breakfast that tastes like it came from a luxury hotel kitchen.
When I first served this at a holiday brunch, my guests couldn't believe it wasn't from a restaurant. The way the caramel creates a self-saucing bottom layer while baking is pure breakfast magic.
Essential Ingredients and Selection Tips
- Brioche bread: Choose a loaf that's slightly stale - fresh bread won't absorb as well
- Brown sugar: Dark brown sugar provides the richest caramel flavor
- Half-and-half: Creates the perfect custard consistency
- Pure vanilla extract: Splurge on real vanilla for the best flavor
- Unsalted butter: Allows precise control of saltiness
- Large eggs: Must be room temperature for even custard
Step-by-Step Instructions
Create the Caramel Base
- Melt butter slowly to prevent separation
- Add brown sugar and stir until completely smooth
- Cook until slightly thickened but still pourable
- Spread evenly to coat entire pan bottom
Pin it
Layer the Bread
- Cut uniform slices about 1-inch thick
- Arrange in a single layer, edges touching
- Press gently into caramel layer
- Fill any gaps with smaller pieces
Prepare the Custard
- Whisk eggs until completely broken up
- Gradually add half-and-half while whisking
- Mix in vanilla and salt until uniform
- Strain mixture for the smoothest texture
Overnight Soak
- Pour custard slowly over bread
- Press bread to encourage absorption
- Cover tightly with plastic wrap
- Refrigerate at least 8 hours
My favorite holiday memory is preparing this with my daughter on Christmas Eve - the anticipation of tomorrow's breakfast made bedtime almost as exciting as waiting for presents.
Make-Ahead Tips
You can prepare the caramel base a day ahead and store it separately, then warm slightly before using.
Seasonal Variations
In fall, I love adding a touch of cinnamon and nutmeg to the custard. During summer, fresh peaches or berries make beautiful additions.
Pin it
After years of making this breakfast treat, I've learned it's more than just a recipe - it's a way to make ordinary mornings feel special. Whether for holidays, celebrations, or just because, this overnight French toast never fails to create memorable moments around the breakfast table.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I use different types of bread?
- Yes! French bread is ideal, but brioche or challah work great too. Just remove thick crusts if using artisan bread.
- → How far ahead can I prepare this?
- Prepare up to 24 hours in advance. The minimum soak time is 8-10 hours for best results.
- → Can I make it softer/more custardy?
- Yes! Increase to 1½ cups half-and-half and 5 eggs instead of 4 for a softer texture.
- → Can I use a different syrup?
- Yes, corn syrup or pancake syrup can substitute for maple syrup in the caramel base.
- → Why put it in a cold oven?
- Starting in a cold oven helps the casserole heat evenly, preventing the bottom from burning before the center sets.